Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee Reviews by Natives
The Story Speaks Louder Than This Film
Bury MY Eye AT WOUNDED KNEE is a somber retelling of the events leading up to the massacre at (what is now) the Wounded Knee Memorial. But this isn't a documentary. This is a made-for-TV fictional retelling, and it is the "made-for-TV" chip that makes this important American event lose some of its composure.
The unabridged production flags considering of the Idiot box aspect, many of the film shots losing their impact either considering of lack of attention to item or funds (or probably both). Either mode this could've been an extreme visual recollection for most viewers but instead it lacks the depth I would've liked to take seen.
Regardless, at that place are some stellar appearances and acting inside information technology. August Schellenberg as Sitting Bull undeniably has the almost touch. Recent movie viewers will probably think him from his portrayal as Powhatan in THE NEW Earth. The dissimilarity between the grapheme in The New World and here in Wounded Human knee shouldn't be lost, either. Without Powhatan and Pocahontas, the white settlers at Jamestown would've perished within the first few winters. And now, in Wounded Articulatio genus, it is the white man who destroys what is left of Native American life; a terribly stark (and bloody) reality.
The other notables are Adam Embankment (FLAGS OF OUR FATHERS) as Charles Eastman, and Aidan Quinn equally Senator Henry Dawes. They spend a lot of time together on film and they played against/off each other exceptionally well. Charles being the "new moving ridge" Indian who melds into the white man's way of life until exposed to reservation life at Pine Ridge. Henry Dawes seeing himself as "The Great White Savior Of The Indians" past passing legislation that loops a few nooses around the necks of the Plains Indians' manner of life without even realizing it.
But other actors take fiddling to offer. Anna Paquin (X-MEN) every bit Charles' white love interest (and eventual wife) is seen also infrequently and then the relationship betwixt the two has little impact. She does a expert job of acting but the script stymied any possibility of existent success. From here the acting dips into the drab and boring. I have to give mention to Senator Fred Thompson (currently a Republican runner for the U.South. Presidency) who plays President Ulysses S. Grant. We see perhaps four frames of film with him in it and and so he's gone. This surprised me greatly since it was Grant's administration that doomed Native Americans by rounding them up and placing them on reservations.
Despite my misgivings nigh the script, cinematography and acting, this is a vital story that needs to be told, and information technology isn't something that is normally taught in grade school or higher. Europeans (us) conquered this land and its people, and pushed them into property pens where they, to this day, await justice for our multiple treaty violations and massacres of their men, women and children (I will say that the scenes depicting large-caliber burglarize bullets ripping through immature kids was filmed well and was equally hard to sentry).
So the story gives this motion picture a higher rating than anything inside information technology, which is unfortunate, as this terrible moment in American history needs to be remembered simply equally much as Frg needs to remember its holocaust.
37 out of 41 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Powerful Drama
It'south no secret that movies mix a lot of fiction with the facts. This film seems to take rubbed both history buffs and fans of the book the wrong mode, but I thought it was a compelling, evocative film withal.
Starting off where most movies end, at a CGI created overhead shot of The Trivial Big Horn (!), this instead focuses on the final years of the Unions war confronting the Indian nations, culminating in the massacre at Wounded Knee.
In that location's a really neat office for Adam Embankment, as a young Souix doctor, who'due south begetter turned his back on the native ways and sent him to live amongst whites at a young age, stripping him of his identity.
August Schellenberg is excellent here equally Sitting Bull, who'south conclusion and pride stokes the anger of the powers that be, including Aiden Quinn, a sympathetic only patronizing Senator who has taken information technology upon himself to atomic number 82 the Indians on a path to "civilisation".
Anyone who watched the myriad Cavalry pictures and Little Big Horn epics should see this and notice out how the whole sad story ends.
5 out of 5 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
"So we will have a fight."
Alert: Spoilers
I'll take to admit that I tried reading Dee Brown'southward "Bury My Eye at Wounded Knee" on two separate occasions, the last time quite recently, and I found information technology to be VERY dry. Maybe that was only in the early going, merely I wasn't able to complete it both times. As for the picture show, I came beyond information technology quite by accident at my local library, not being an HBO subscriber. If I had my druthers, I approximate I'd side with those reviewers who experience a more complete story could accept been told using a mini-series format. Nonetheless given the medium, it's a compelling film that highlights the plight of the Native American Indian in the dying days of the Old Due west, and with information technology, the decease knell of a proud warrior people.
I recently visited the James Fenimore Cooper Museum in Cooperstown, New York, and at the time, actual Sioux drawings were on exhibit depicting the Battle at Petty Big Horn. Watching the aerial view of the attack on screen all of a sudden put into perspective the circular rendition of an artist'south rendering on a total size tee-pee. Information technology was like seeing a painting come to life with a soaring eagle'due south eye, peradventure devoid of detail, but breathtaking in it's panoramic perspective on the immensity of the boxing. Not to mention the hopelessness of Custer'southward cause.
The moving picture tin can be admittedly depressing at times with it's depiction of outright slaughter, and peradventure even more so once the Sioux tribes are relegated to reservation life. We get to see how the 'Every Human being a Chief' designation, though sounding completely egalitarian, works to strip away a proud main's identity and condition within his nation. I'thou actually glad that the flick didn't explore Sitting Balderdash's Wild West Show days with Buffalo Nib. Fortunately, he was able to reaffirm his own dignity with the 'one last time' confrontation against Senator Dawes (Aidan Quinn), a legacy that remains standing to this day.
Squeamish performances all around past Aidan Quinn as Senator Dawes, Adam Beach equally the conflicted Ohiyesa/Charles Eastman, and August Schellenberg as Sitting Bull. President Grant came and went likewise quickly for me to recognize Fred Thompson under the beard, a trait he might as well suffer equally a Presidential contender unless he gets that burn down in the belly.
9 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Wounded Knee joint merely without the Heart
Alert: Spoilers
This well intentioned moving-picture show did not capture the spirit of Dee Dark-brown'south book, alas.
Focusing the story largely around the admirable Lakota doctor, Charles Eastman and his White wife tries to requite an emotional eye to Chocolate-brown'south sprawling narrative but the characters of Sitting Bull and Reddish Cloud come off as little more than an elaboration of the famous "Noble Redman meets Litter" commercial of the 70's. Superficial, blatantly sentimental and ultimately, not all that stirring----although I loved the aerial cinematic dance of the Battle of the Little Bighorn.
HBO would take been better off following the narrative construction of the book---a compelling and heartrending documentation of the woes, duplicity and failures of communication over several hundred years that ultimately achieved the about genocide of the native peoples of America by the turn of the 20th Century.
Perhaps a miniseries could take achieved this.
Ultimately, this HBO production had footling heart to bury.
49 out of 60 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Excellent movie...not given plenty credit.
Warning: Spoilers
The but reason I am giving this movie an "8" is considering I can see why some people might be confused. Othewise, I cannot understand so much negativity towards this moving-picture show.
I will admit that I may have a slight reward based on existence raised past a mother who knows her Indian history and in particular, her Lakota history. I have too been to the surface area around Pine Ridge several times, so envisioning it wasn't hard.
Without being able to exercise a 4 or v hour production, I remember they did an outstanding job of showing the plight of the Native people and their struggle to be under unfair and harsh conditions. It was rather apparently to me and not colored over for the sake of the film. Showing the reality of Sitting Bull as a leader, as a man, as a convict was eloquent and very existent to me.
Aidan Quinn was excellent in portraying a Christian man who honestly felt he was doing the right thing, simply operating without a total understanding of what was beingness taken for the people he thought he was helping. Adam Embankment did a great job of playing a young man disillusioned by the world he was forced into and saddened past what was happening to his people.
Some of the best moments of the motion-picture show seemed elementary outwardly, just were in fact so powerful that I cried. When Charles has his braids cut earlier going off to school, I felt and so deplorable at that office of his civilization being stripped from him. When the Indian men are lined up at Charles's window, asking for cod liver oil for the alcohol content, and when Sitting Bull arrives at the bureau and is told that he no better than any other man there, those are some powerful moments. In fact, there were and then many, I cannot count. Possibly my favorite was the conversation between Gall and Sitting Bull in which Gall basically tells Sitting Bull that he has sold out and how much information technology has injure him because of his view of him every bit a man who would never give up.
The only problems I could even mention about the picture is that at times it was hard to know who was who. It took me until the second time of watching to realize who was Gall and who was American Horse.
Watching all of the extras and commentary on this film gave me even more than of an appreciation for what was attempting to exist told in this film.
xviii out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Must they adjust to the extent of their own extinction!
The trail of tears that lead to the massacre at Wounded Human knee on December 29, 1890 started in the Summer of 1876 at the Petty Big Horn. It was in that location where Gen. George Armstrong Custer and over 250 men under his command was slaughtered to the last man, the merely survivor of Custer's troop being a calvary horse called Comanche, by the fired up Sioux Indians.
Wanting revenge for what turned out to be the worst defeat that the Us Calvary suffered in the Indian Wars the "Great White Begetter" President Ulysses S. Grant, Fred Thompson, sent a much bigger military detachment headed by, every bit he'due south chosen by the Sioux, Gen.Bear-Coat to put a final stop to the Dakota Indian insurgence. Against Chief Sitting Bull, August Schellenberg, and his some 3 grand warriors at Ceder Valley Creek Gen. Bear-Coat had no trouble dispersing the Sioux onslaught mowing down hundreds of Sitting Bull's men with volleys of burglarize and cannon fire.
Dispersed and on the brink of starvation Sitting Balderdash's rival Chief Red Cloud, Gordon Tootoosis, was forced to sign abroad his peoples rights to where they became wards of the state living off the kindness and charity of the hated White Man. Sitting Balderdash wanting none of this took his followers to Canada where later suffering through a number of harsh Canadian Winters, far worse so any of the winters in the Dakota Territories, subsequently came dorsum chapeau in hand accepting the unthinkable: living under the White Man'southward both rule and law. It was the deception and manipulation by the US Government in trying to force Sitting Balderdash and his people to sign away their ancestral lands that eventually pb to the wild and hysterical events that lead to Wounded Knee.
The story of "Bury My Centre at Wounded Knee" is told to us through the personal observations of Charles Eastman, Adam Embankment, formerly known by his Sioux Indian proper name of Ohiyesa. Eastman was an 18 year old at the boxing of Little Large Horn where he earned his warrior'southward plume in killing a horse soldier of Gen. Custer'due south 7th Calvary in the fighting. Now grown up and earning a medical degree Eastman simply wants to assist his beau Sioux in preventing a number of deadly outbreaks of disease that hit his one-time dwelling house the Pino Ridge Indian Reservation.
Together with his white European wife the sometime Elaine Goodale, Anna Paguin, Eastman worked effectually the clock trying to save what he could of the many Sioux Indians who were dying past the hundreds of both hunger and disease. With Eastman's proficient friend Massachusetts Senator Henry Drew, Alden Quinn,trying to become his people to come up to some agreement with the Usa Government in becoming farmers instead of nomads, which the Sioux were for countless centuries, tensions soon reached a breaking point.
It was when out of sheer desperation the Sioux adopted the aboriginal Indian Ghost Dance, which was only ceremonial and nothing else, that the US Army was dispatched to put an stop to what the Federal Government back in Washington D.C perceived to exist some other potential Petty Big Horn. With tempers flaring on both sides after Main Sitting Bull was murdered by the reservations Sioux police force information technology was just a matter of time for the hat, that both Eastman and Senator Drew tried to go along on, blew off and the results was the massacre at Wounded Knee joint. The last major battle between the US war machine and American Indians in the long and bloody United states/Indian Wars of the 1800's.
Pretty authentic film about how the American Indians were treated and how they had their land which they never really claimed to ain, the thought of a person owning a piece of state was unknown to them, from right under noses. Despite the many losses they suffered at the easily of the US Military the Sioux never relinquished their claim to the Blackness Hills, which they considered their sacred and holy grounds. Technically and legally even now, some 118 years after the Wounded Knee massacre, the historic Black Hills are in the hands of the Sioux tribes still living there.
P.South Charles Eastman aka Ohiyesa was to write dozens of books and articles well-nigh his people the Sioux Indians also as practice medicine at the Pine Ridge, also as other, Indian reservation until he passed away on January 8, 1939 at the age of 80. Eastman amongst his many accomplishments in the service of his people was as well the co-founder of the American Male child Scouts that improved and enriched the lives of American youths white black yellow and Native American Indian alike.
16 out of 24 plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Uneven, incomplete, and slow depiction of the story
Very tedious moving movie, which detracted greatly from the story it should accept been telling. If y'all oasis't read the book, or knew nothing of the history of this story, you would be completely lost.
The bandage was not bad, and the interim was good. It is not the actors fault that the direction and editing was terrible. I had high hopes that the story telling would be straight frontward, of a relatively well-documented event, based on the well known book.
The title is misleading; information technology is not Bury My Heart at Wounded Articulatio genus, it is a pocket-size excerpt combined with some other story I was not familiar with. The ending of the movie is really mangled, combining color with black and white for dramatic effect, but information technology but doesn't work, especially when it never even shows the upshot depicted in the title.
Watch it for adept acting, good music, great camera piece of work, just don't wait to be educated, or entertained. The atrocities committed upon this Indian nation deserves a better rendition and remembrance, than presented hither.
67 out of 108 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
What a Letdown
Warning: Spoilers
I call back reading Dee Brownish'due south volume when I was about twelve, and beingness stunned by how powerful and moving it was. And then when I saw that HBO was making a movie of Bury My Heart, I was thrilled.
And and so I actually watched it.
Why they chose to take such a complex story and cram it into a two hour movie is beyond me -- they certainly could have made it a miniseries, a la Band of Brothers, or something. All the centre and soul of Brownish's volume is lost in this movie.
And I know Adam Beach is a popular actor if you're casting a picture that calls for immature, good looking Native American guys, but he merely has two facial expressions: happy or snarly, and that'due south it. Even Aidan Quinn, whom I normally adore, was totally wooden in this. The magnificent Wes Studi was horribly underused; he appears for about threescore seconds of film.
Such a shame that an amazing story had to exist turned into a disappointing production.
32 out of 45 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Awesome picture...
I accept never read the entire volume. Only the movie, as far equally I'one thousand concerned is outstanding. I actually idea it was going to exist nothing but gun touting action and a lot of fluff, simply the movie does well in showing the accuracies in most of the accounts that happened or would have happened. The movie does a good job showing a more sympathetic side to some of the Americans who actually cared for the Indian'south and their interests. Simply it was likewise true in showing the ignorance on both sides and lack of agreement what truly needs to be done to attain peace. Another good thing that I loved about this movie was that is showed a more internal/personal conflict with the characters, something rarely encounter in Indian based movies or historically ones at that. Overall it is an awesome movie that I think, if shown in some of my history classes, would make that subject a lot more interesting. Anyone waiting to see the John Adams movie?
41 out of 56 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An HBO flop
Everything and everyone involved in this product was presented in such a style equally to be a cliché, an unfortunate stereotype of the real events and people this show was based upon. It'southward really sad because I would take expected so much more than from HBO. In by programs they take done such an splendid chore of portraying an era, Rome being one very effective example. And it even more of a shame because the book this cloth is based upon was so thoroughly unique. I read "Bury My Heart At Wounded Genu" the summer of the year it was published. I was a senior in loftier schoolhouse on my mode to college and I was really taken aback by it'due south powerful and intense telling of those years in American history.
The book left such an impression on me. I felt then aroused and mistrustful toward the traditional telling of history, or our "non" telling of history that I spend a great deal of time talking with my relatives and grandparents nigh their recall of native people they had known and worked with.
My paternal grandparents were from Topeka Kansas and my uncle had worked for a number of years at the Agency Of Land Management, which had reservations as one of it'due south business organization. My uncle somewhen told me the reason he left, was he merely couldn't deal with the wretchedness of the whole matter. He said the health of the Indians was appalling and that the money they were supposed to be getting never got to whom information technology should. It finally depressed him so much he transferred to another expanse of government. I always remembered my grandfather, who was non a wealthy homo, donated much money to what he used to call "The Indian Missions". They were always sending him Christian paraphernalia as thank yous, which he kept in special alcoves and shelves in his bedchamber. To my child'due south listen they were magnificently beautiful... most of them were plastic and many lit upwardly in the dark. I used to sleep in that room when we visited in the summers. He e'er had a special place in his middle for the mission people, and since he was a really kind and generous man, I realized they must be too. In those days Indians were still outsiders and while my own family may have thought otherwise, many of the people who lived in that function of the land regarded anyone who was not white equally sub-human being. I never got to ask my grandparents about the Indians because they were dead by the time I read this volume and got curious.
Anyway, that is all a tangent story. The fact remains that this production falls style short of the base of operations material and is an HBO bomb as far as I'yard concerned. Perchance they should have made it a total fledged mini series and explored the richness of the characters further, particularly the Ghost Dancer, considering it's a gripping story well worth big attention.
75 out of 125 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Wait, nosotros need to own upwards to what we did to the Indians.
Does "Coffin My Middle at Wounded Knee" go overboard on trying to humanize its subjects (or making them palatable to a TV audience)? Whether or non information technology does is beside the point. The point hither is that nosotros white people take to own upwards to our genocide against the Indians and theft of their land. Even if information technology takes a less-than-masterful movie like this ane, something needs to remind us of that. The movie focuses specifically on a Sioux (Adam Beach) who takes the name Charles Eastman and studies medicine, but upon seeing what the white people's west expansion does to his people tries to go Sen. Henry Dawes (Aidan Quinn) to listen.
I recommend information technology just considering information technology shows what happened to the Indians. I repeat: we white people need to acknowledge what we did and start atoning for it. Also starring J.M. Simmons, Wes Studi, August Schellenberg and Anna Paquin.
29 out of 68 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Bury the Truth of Wounded Articulatio genus
Warning: Spoilers
The Wounded Knee joint Massacre (aka The Battle at Wounded Genu Creek) was the final major armed disharmonize of what Americans term the "Indian Wars" of the late nineteenth century. Movie opens with a recreation of soldiers taking pictures of "Big Foot in Decease," one of the disturbing actual pictures in the volume, taken on the Wounded Knee battlefield in 1890.
When I read Coffin My Middle at Wounded Genu over a decade ago, I would never take believed that White America would have the gall to turn it into a film – and if it was made into a movie, it would be diluted equally a trail of tears… The latter has come up to laissez passer.
Screenwriter Daniel Giat and director Yves Simoneau deliver a flick as watery as any American beer. Though it is supposedly a tribute to the dogged spirit of the Native Americans, it is still another White-Perspective slur-fest that dishonors that wild race with every bigoted frame. How could any motion-picture show on Earth convey the inhuman horrors of Custer's men playing soccer with the heads of Native American children? The movie opens with General Custer's gruesome defeat at Little Large Horn in 1876 by combined Lakota and Northern Cheyenne Native Americans – but we don't run across the heads that were simply a function of the reason why the slaughter was inevitable and well-deserved. The picture ends with the grisly massacre of Lakota Sioux men, women and children at Wounded Knee joint in 1890. Almost as if the "Indians" got their but desserts for killing them nice soldier boys.
I residuum my case.
(By the way, "Indians" is the White Optics' name for the Native American races. The Native peoples refer to themselves either as Native Americans or their tribe name. When the Natives in this movie telephone call themselves Indians and then offhandedly, we realize the film-makers did all their inquiry on Wikipedia.) It was not bad enough to impale off the Native Americans 150 years ago, now a flick is made about that inhuman era – not to honor the Natives, but to MAKE Money for HBO; to pretend a spirituality, tolerance and political definiteness modern Americans take not the depth to cover.
Before we continue, let us establish that Dee Brown's 1970 book is a disturbing, thought-provoking, well-researched masterpiece; a towering indictment of frontier America of the 1800s; a history lesson from the people who lived it, non the ones who re-wrote it. Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee is a book that scarred the self-aggrandizing perspective of a nation; recounting Native Americans' extermination at the hands of the White Eyes and their broken promises, cowardly massacres and encarmine betrayals; every single treaty betwixt the two factions dishonored past the scoundrels who claimed birthright to a country that they knew was not theirs.
Though this gutless filmic re-imagining of Dark-brown's book tries hard to be compelling, it is merely a thin marketing gimmick for whatever Native American fever was doing the rounds in Hollywood at the time.
The actors do what they can with the clichéd characters they're assigned: Aidan Quinn every bit the Good White Man, empowered to carve upwardly land and herd the Native Americans out; the majestic Wes Studi, an onetime-school agitator; August Schellenberg perfectly cast equally Sitting Balderdash, "the greatest living Indian"; Eric Schweig doing his Steven Segal impersonation; the magnificent Adam Beach (Flags of Our Fathers), one pace closer to some kind of acting award; Nathan Lee Chasing His Equus caballus (evocative name, no? – he played the young Smiles A Lot in Dances With Wolves) is Sitting Bull's son; and playing the president better than he ever could in existent life, Fred Thompson every bit Ulysses S. Grant.
At first, the White Eyes' grasping at existent manor looks like provincialism and ignorance of different cultures ("I however believe that setting the Indians on the course to civilization best serves him") simply the Illegal Aliens (i.east. American settlers) knew full well that they wanted the Land under the PRETENSE of doing a good deed for the Natives – doublespeaking it equally mendaciously as that Great Globe Terrorist of the 2000s, George W. Bush ("Nosotros're spreading democracy (and so we're killing them for their free energy resource)"). Of form, this proud, atomic number 26-skinned people, their faces etched like rocks of ages, knew better - and also knew inherent grand truths that their White Eyes scourges could never grasp: that the Country belongs to no one, that we are all a Function OF the land. Unfortunately, there is something stronger than pride – genocide.
Not all the stupidities in this movie are the film-makers' or the early settlers' fault, though. We easily criticize the flick for all the Natives conveniently speaking English in current American vernacular and ooga-booga emphasis, which simply screams "Made For Television," but other silliness can be attributed to the Native Americans and their own bogus "spirituality": Wes Studi preaches that if they all do The Trip the light fantastic toe they volition live forever.. uh, ooookay. And I know a modernistic Native friend who still fasts for a week and nails himself to a tree every Tree-Nailing Flavour and and then swears he has "visions" – of Form you lot have visions! You're hallucinating from food deprivation and blood loss!
Our only hope is that viewers of this vapid HBO movie will be encouraged to read Brown's book and perform true-hearted enquiry into the buried heritage that the White Eyes are yet working so hard to pretend to forget.
15 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Very adept film.
Alarm: Spoilers
I believed this film to be quite accurate throughout with one blemish. The concluding major scene ... the 1 of the actual massacre. The film portrays it as starting "past an accidental shot" by ane of the villagers belongings a gun. I believe that to exist wrong! The fact is that the soldiers just went correct in in that location to shoot and kill! Non ane mention was fabricated of this in the picture show. There was NO prelude, if y'all will, to the mass murders considering right later on Sitting Bull was shot and killed the soldiers/constabulary went directly to the hamlet to murder all his supporters. It was Sitting Balderdash who rose up over again with his Lakota ppl in disobedience of the whites because he still felt at that place was still a risk to salvage the erstwhile ways. So, right after Sitting Bull was shot, the soldiers weren't satisfied. So they proceeded to that village then that they could take killed more Lakota!! The massacre DID NOT showtime by an accidental discharge as it's portrayed in the movie! You noticed that soon later on the head commander told Charles Eastman that they "did not burn down the first shot, I swear past the almighty God" ... those were the words right after he helped murder the Lakota. So not but did he aid murder them just he as well lied to Eastman! This picture is a classic portrayal of murder, treachery and deceit past the whites as is Ever the instance! And Dawes was NOT a friend of Eastman'southward! Dawes but USED HIM to get what he wanted and what every white man wanted .... Lakota land, resources and wealth, that'due south all!! In that location was no such matter as "friendship" between whites and Native ppl in those days! If there was, it was ordinarily the white person only wanting to use and corruption him/her, usually for state, money, resources; you know, the usual shebang.
Simply... ANYWAYS... this was withal a great movie to sentinel for those interested in Native history and I would strongly recommend you watch it.
3 out of 4 establish this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Congrats, HBO
Having just spent the by 18 months studying Native American philosophy and having just returned from a calendar week at Cherokee, learning the language and culture up close, I can say this motion picture does help limited the complex and heart-rending story of the human relationship between the invaders and the conquered in our years 1870-1890.
For those who take been critical of the moving picture (on this site), I should annotation from a White Woman'south point of view, this is most all that Whites can blot of the "total" story and emotions every bit a first contact. Yes, more than tin be told and should exist told. But information technology's a start.
Perhaps this is the beginning of a revival of compassion and cross-cultural understanding.
In 1775, Dragging Canoe, a Cherokee, said, "We are non yet conquered." It has taken 200 years. Let's hope he was right.
13 out of twenty plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A big disappointment
The only reason I'm giving this motion-picture show iii stars is because of the casting and the interim. Both were well done. The movie, nonetheless, is a disappointment.
I kickoff read Dee Dark-brown's book, Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee joint, when I was 10 years quondam and found out that I was part Cherokee. It struck a cord with me that continues to resonate today, 30 some years later. Expecting a long overdue movie that would capture the eloquent and heart-breaking words and stories of the book, I was disappointed to find the film barely resembled the book at all. As a college lecturer who ofttimes refers to the book in my classes, I am quite familiar with its contents. The movie version was barely recognizable.
Indian heroes such as Sitting Balderdash and Red Deject come across every bit arrogant and foolish in this movie. They are not characters that we can sympathize with; in fact, no one in this moving picture is. While the story of Charles Eastman is worth telling, information technology is non part of the book and is sloppily woven into the storyline of the Sioux resistance at the Battle of the Piddling Bighorn to the massacre at Wounded Genu. That the Wounded Knee massacre should exist told in flashbacks rather than as direct action is appalling.
And so much has been left out of this movie that information technology does nothing more than commit a great injustice to both the book and the people whose stories are being told. Hasn't America taken enough away from the Indian? Must another Hollywood movie strip Indian people of yet another attribute of their culture, namely their stories, their history, and their heroes? In this film, information technology does all three.
31 out of 56 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Clumsy treatment of a fascinating story
When the government of America'southward European settlers defeated the ethnic population, they didn't directly massacre or enslave them (at least, not in every case). The signed a treaty with the defeated Sioux that granted them land, and when they wanted some of this back, offered to pay for it. Senator Henry Dawes, architect of this deal, saw himself as a great friend on the Indians (equally opposed to those who considered them sub-human); he was offering them civilisation. Withal, anthropologist Marvin Harris has suggested that the process of civilisation is non so much progress as a necessary adaptation to shortages of natural resources, particularly land, and the truth of this is apparent when considering the Sioux; regardless of whether civilisation was truly in their interests, it was necessary to release their land to those who wished to exploit it. 'Bury My Center At Wounded Human knee' tells the story of this catamenia, and the truth is grim and fascinating; but unfortunately, this is heavy-handed stuff, whose sympathies are ever apparent, and marred by wooden acting and lumbering dialogue. In place of naturalism, almost every scene seems peculiarly constructed to demonstrate a specific bespeak of the history; and bizarrely, the story's natural climax is told, not every bit it happens, only in flashback, squandering the dramatic tension that should have been apparent. Yet in spite of its clumsiness, the pic left me wanting to know more of the real history; in that at to the lowest degree it succeeds.
3 out of 10 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Exceptionaly skilful.
Warning: Spoilers
An HBO Films event inspired past Dee Brown's bestseller. A true epic that begins with the backwash of the Sioux massacre of General Custer and his men at Little Big Horn. Featured are the struggles of three principal players every bit Senator Dawes(Aidan Quinn)lobbies President Grant(Fred Thompson)into treating the Indians kinder. Senator Dawes would be aided by Charles Eastman(Adam Beach), a young Sioux doctor educated At Dartmouth. The Dawes Commission agenda was to break up the Great Sioux Reservation into individual parcels of land to exist awarded to each Indian and notwithstanding allow a right of fashion for the railroad to traverse on their former lands. The great chief Sitting Bull(August Schellnberg) would exist driven to Canada then reluctantly return to the reservation, where he would be stripped of his powers and nobility. Elaine Goodale(Anna Paquin)who's secret dearest of Eastman led her to the reservation to piece of work in improving the lives of the Indians. Smashing scenery and superbly photographed. Also featured are: Wes Studi, J.M. Simmons, Colm Feorce, Gordon Tootoosis and Eric Schweig.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Substantially the sequel to 1991's "Son of the Morning Star"
Released to HBO in 2007, "Bury My Center at Wounded Knee" is a historical Western based on several chapters of Dee Brown's book of the same proper name and details the last days of the Sioux Nation, culminating in the infamous massacre at Wounded Knee. Adam Embankment plays Charles Eastman, a Dakota youth who is encouraged by his Christianized father to head due east and become a medico. During his stint every bit doc at Pino Ridge Reservation he meets and marries, Elaine Goodale (Anna Paquin). Eastman teams-upwards with Senator Henry Dawes (Aidan Quinn) to legally help the Native Americans. This includes the Dawes Human activity, which would ensure that every Indian family would own 160 acres of state. Inside this framework the story of Sitting Bull (August Schellenberg) is told, including his death. Wes Studi appears briefly as Wovoka, a Northern Paiute spiritual leader and creator of the Ghost Trip the light fantastic toe. His messianic movement inspired the Natives, promising an end of their suffering under white rule.
Every flick based on history mixes fact with fiction as filmmakers try to overcome the challenge of morphing circuitous existent-life events into palatable movie house. Then let's get the falsities out of the way: Charles Eastman never lived in the Native village virtually the Boxing of the Little Bighorn every bit young brave Ohiyesa; Sitting Balderdash surrendered at Ft. Buford, not Continuing Stone; lastly, Charles Eastman was not Dawes' associate in developing the Dawes Act.
With that out of the manner, what I like nearly this movie is how counterbalanced it is as it shows both sides of the story. Here the Indians aren't portrayed as super-virtuous with about-Messianic powers (except for Wovoka, which is understandable) nor are the whites frothing with evil to massacre the Natives. This balance is perfectly portrayed in the excellent parley sequence between Sitting Bull and Col. Nelson Miles (Shaun Johnston) where honest and intense positions are shared. For example, Miles argues that Due north America was anything but a peaceful paradise before Europeans arrived and that the Lakota Sioux conquered other tribes to acquire "their" land in the Black Hills. The Europeans were simply a confederation of several white "tribes" from across the great bounding main and were merely doing the same thing that Sitting Bull'due south tribe did – acquiring land from conquered peoples.
Speaking of Sitting Bull, he's one of the most interesting and enigmatic Native characters seen in movie theater. And it's a noteworthy performance by Schellenberg.
The Wovoka sequence is another highlight where Wovoka (Studi) brings his prophecy and message of the Ghost Trip the light fantastic to the Black Hills Natives. He articulates his bulletin in a hypnotizing fashion accompanied by the sign language of the plains Indians. The irony is that, while Wovoka's vision inspires the Lakota and it replaces their suffering with promise & happiness, it only ends in death.
2 great sequences occur in the concluding act: The accurately-depicted haunting death of Sitting Bull, which took place on December 15, 1890, at Standing Rock Reservation; and the titular massacre at Wounded Knee joint Creek on the Pine River Reservation two weeks subsequently. Col. James Forsyth (Marty Antonini) says to Eastman, "We didn't fire kickoff. I swear to Omnipotent God, we did not fire offset," which is verified by history: Tensions mounted in the confrontation as Yellow Bird started to perform the Ghost Dance, informing the Sioux that their "ghost shirts" were bulletproof. Known troublemaker Black Coyote seemed to unintentionally trigger the massacre past refusing to requite upwardly his rifle; some say he was deaf and didn't comprehend the club. When two soldiers seized Black Coyote from behind, his burglarize was discharged during the struggle. While this was happening, Yellow Bird threw grit in the air and several Lakota braves with concealed weapons threw aside their blankets and fired their rifles at the troops. The firing and then became indiscriminate and the massacre entailed.
While "Bury My Middle at Wounded Genu" is a tv set production, its quality is equally good or meliorate than many theatrical pictures. As my title blurb says, it'south basically the sequel to 1991'south "Son of the Morn Star": That movie concluded with Custer's last stand whereas "Wounded Knee" begins with information technology. Furthermore, they're both televisions productions with the same grueling-realistic tone. Some other good comparing is 1975'due south "I Will Fight No More than Forever." It's too not far off in manner and approach to movies like "Unforgiven" (1992), "Wyatt Earp" (1994) and "Open Range" (2003). If you lot're a fan of these types of Westerns be sure to bank check out "Bury My Heart at Wounded Articulatio genus."
The film runs 133 minutes and was shot exterior of Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Form: B+
1 out of ii institute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
HBO dropped the ball on this one
I'yard rarely if always disappointed past whatever movies HBO makes, but I was disappointed plenty with wasting two hours on this ane that I felt compelled to say something. Anyone looking for a moving business relationship of a profoundly tragic and shameful event in American history ought to keep looking. Don't get me started...
OK, fine! If I came into this motion picture with no agreement of how the United states Regime screwed the Sioux out of their land (and this was the case), I still have no idea how, when, where, or why this happened. Which land? Why was information technology so precious to them? Why did the United states of america want it? What were the specifics of the homestead program nosotros tried to impose? Why didn't the Sioux just take the money? The movie simply throws you into the middle of their numerous town-hall sessions and expects you to know what's going on. The movie did nothing to capture the stark beauty of that land, the spirituality of the civilization, didn't go far enough back to show you what they were missing, what they were trying to regain. It would have been squeamish to see a real buffalo chase to recognize what a pathetic sham the reservation buffalo-chase simulator was. The Sioux are only shown to exist a bunch of stubborn, troublesome, raggedy refugees, so the sympathy merely isn't there.
How does Adam Beach continue getting work? I realize in that location's probably a scarcity of Native American actors out at that place, just this guy's the eye of your story and he'south got the emotional range of a low-cal switch. He was atrocious in WINDTALKERS and he'south awful here. You can really sense how lost he is playing off Anna Paquin and Aidan Quinn.
What the heck was with those lilliputian photo-montage-transition thingies? The movie was irksome enough without the director throwing those pictures in there to assist bring information technology to a screeching halt multiple times. Information technology'south as if he was just trying to requite a shout-out to the makeup people and casting agents: "Ooooh, look how we made this guy look like THAT guy! Yay for u.s.a.!" If anything, it only helped embalm his story even more by tying it to the past with semi-relevant onetime tintypes instead of making it live and exhale. Whatever else he was going for, I missed it.
Finally, nosotros come to the climax(?) of the piece, the massacre itself, which is only recounted in a flashback, with no build-up, no clear nuts-and-bolts demonstration of the hate-whitey all-dark rave parties thrown by the fed-up Sioux, and no clear motivation supplied by the men who sent in the soldiers. I'd take to watch it once again, just they didn't fifty-fifty say how many people on both sides bought the farm, and it was an extremely bloody matter. If they were trying to present the whole story through the optics of the doctor, I would have understood a dorsum-handed recounting since he wasn't at the creek, merely the moving-picture show switched narratives multiple times, so the directing and editing and even storytelling decisions don't build any tension at all. You could have had a Native American version of DO THE Correct THING here and y'all BLEW IT!!! One minute, everyone's huddled in blankets complaining nearly crummy treaties, and the next BAM!!! Expressionless, frozen Sioux.
What happened at Wounded Knee is the crowning nightmare in a catalog of infamies washed to our Native American brothers. I wanted to be angry after watching this, possibly even choked up a bit. No dice. Possibly the well-nigh affecting moment in the movie is a closing title proverb the Sioux have never to this date taken a dime for the Black Hills, implying that they're all the same doin' the Ghost Trip the light fantastic, waiting for Whitey to destroy himself (won't be long) so they can but move back in. When a closing championship is the most compelling thing in your film, you lot're in trouble.
30 out of 69 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Not highly memorable, merely informative.
Looking through the reviews, there seem to be lots of people complaining that this wasn't a $100million 5 part ballsy with nigh of the dialogue in Sioux. Still, HBO should be congratulated for simply making this motion-picture show.
The movie could be best described as informative, well-nigh events that probably few people know anything about. It covers quite a lot of territory, and renders it digestible.
The movie has the usual Television set syle photographic camera methods. The interim is a little wooden, and parts are clichéd. It likewise tries to include the events, the legal matters, and personal stories, which is always difficult, only succeeds to a reasonable degree. There's a story about a young Sioux man and his white wife threaded in, probably to terminate the picture simply beingness nigh the Sioux and white bureaucrats and soldiers. But this is the price of getting an audience.
Non highly memorable, just informative and interesting. Pretty adept, by the standards of television movies of the time. Who knows, perchance by 2100 there volition exist a film nearly how the The states conquered/stole half of Mexico too.
4 out of vii found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A good story about another American anathema
At that place is no doubt that the three greatest Travesties in the history of America are the treatment of the Native Americans, the handling of the Mexicans, and the treatment of the Blacks. All three were accented abominations on the soul of America. And absolute proof of the evil that lurks in the heart of the many white men. I've always considered white men to be the most dangerous people on the Earth. And I all the same consider them to be that. And I say that as a white man, who has a very limited amount of pride, based on the travesties we've committed over the centuries.
Sure, we've accomplished a lot. But at what toll? This was a good movie. It was a expert delineation of but some other travesty that nosotros've committed. And the cowards that were responsible. As a great Indian Warrior once said, courage is very like shooting fish in a barrel at a altitude.
Beach is excellent as usual. Quinn plays a highly flawed human being with good intentions, simply someone who does not really understand the deficiencies of the souls of the lowlife politicians he is surrounded by.
two out of five constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Excellent.
I have no idea whether this is historically accurate, or, if I were a member of (Canada's) Offset Nations, to embrace or be offended by this portrayal of the time period, which, though the story of ane Americanized Indian, is (given the championship) really virtually the plight of America's first peoples and obviously told from a 21st Century perspective. Unlike Clint Eastwood'due south "Letters from Iwo Jima", it is truly a "white man'due south" perception. But, like Eastwood'south "Outlaw Josey Wales", I was happy to embrace the intended sympathy for the characters. As a Canadian, I was besides proud to meet Adam Beach and Canada'south Prairies represent an American history lesson. And, I must mention that, in improver to excellent cinematography, writing,and management, what really made the movie for me was the soundtrack by George South. Clinton. Whether you have no interest in the story of this time period, or are finishing a Doctorate in Anthropology, I believe that you will be touched deeply in viewing this movie.
5 out of 12 plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A reduction
Ric-seven 21 September 2013
I recently constitute this movie in searching for Dee Chocolate-brown's book at the local public library. I call back reading the book when it first came out, decades ago, and I was fascinated--a history book that I could not put downwardly, just similar The Exorcist (the book) when I beginning read information technology. Dee Dark-brown's book was also a horror story, and the major horror was that it was real.
And so knowing absolutely nothing about the motion-picture show, I borrowed it, thinking that it would be essentially a documentary. Was I wrong! I should have just checked out the book and read information technology over again. Celebrated atrocities can only be properly dramatized by extraordinarily gifted filmmakers. Annihilation else is a reduction. Just peradventure it is better if someone stumbles upon the Native American genocide washed up equally a popcorn movie, than never to have any idea at all.
The NY Times review complained of some rather obvious analogies to Iraq and Afghanistan. That further illustrates the reduction--would anyone dare use the Holocaust as an analogy for anything else? I don't error the product, which was polished and accomplished. But HBO should have passed on this.
three out of 9 plant this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Sioux Massacre at Wounded Genu
On December 15, 1890, reservation police tried to arrest Sitting Bull, the famous Sioux chief, and killed him in the process, increasing the tensions at Pine Ridge.
On December 29, the U. Southward. Ground forces's 7th Cavalry surrounded a band of Ghost Dancers nether Big Foot, a Lakota Sioux chief, near Wounded Knee joint Creek and demanded they surrender their weapons. As that was happening, a fight bankrupt out betwixt a Sioux man and a U. S. soldier and a shot was fired, although it'south unclear from which side. A brutal massacre followed, in which it'south estimated 150 Sioux were killed (some historians put this number at twice as high), nearly half of them women and children. The cavalry lost 25 men.
This is the historical event that "Coffin My Heart at Wounded Articulatio genus" leads up to.
The picture show begins in 1876 with General Custer being defeated by Sitting Bull at Niggling Big Horn. That was a temporary victory for the Native American tribe, because eventually they would be driven from their land.
"Bury My Heart" focuses on Ohiyesa aka Charles Eastman (Adam Beach). He was a Sioux who went to American universities to become a doctor. He was a success story in the eyes of many whites because he was a symbol of successful assimilation. He became a projection and protege of Senator Henry Dawes (Aidan Quinn), a homo who wanted to negotiate a means to essentially defraud the Sioux of their land. The good Christian white folks were always good at dressing atrocity up as civility and so hypocritically pointing out the barbarity of others.
"Bury My Heart" was a dorsum and forth between indigenous people and the U. S. regime. Whether it was with guns, words, or "treaties" in that location was a abiding tug-o-war which Native Americans were steadily losing.
I would've loved to see this aforementioned movie with a bigger budget and better production. There were veteran actors in it such as Aidan Quinn and J. Yard. Simmons, and a familiar confront from "10-Men" in Anna Paquin. I wouldn't fifty-fifty change the cast. The story was there, the bandage was at that place, as were the intentions, information technology only lacked the money to go far the product it deserved to be.
HBO Max.
0 out of 0 constitute this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Are Y'all Really Set for the Truth?
First off, I oasis't seen the production of Bury My Middle at Wounded Knee. Only I read the book. Many years ago. But if this production is true to the volume information technology will exist a wake-upward telephone call for many. You'll come away knowing exactly what was done to the people of the First Nations. The false promises, outright lies, cruelty, deprivation forced on them. The grief of seeing your wife, husband, father, child...your unabridged family destroyed. To meet state that had sustained your people for eons existence taken over and divided upwardly, destroyed, its animal life extinguished with no hope of recovery. And finally, to meet the mountains those lands surrounded...mountains sacred to all the tribes and nations of your race...to come across the faces of foreign leaders carved into those mountains. Those of yous with an ability for true empathy might have an inkling of the despair and hopelessness felt by the people of the Start Nations. The majority will feel bad for a brusque while then continue with their lives every bit before. And for some, some volition feel a burden on their soul the likes of which y'all will wish y'all had never known. You'll learn to alive with it. I can promise you that. We whites have an amazing capacity for justifying what our race has done to others and living with its subsequent guilt. But how long can we practice that? Injustices done in the past tin can't exist erased. And the injustice to the Showtime Peoples continues to this twenty-four hours. If racial memory is an actuality, how big a burden of guilt tin can we carry until our collective backs break from its weight?
13 out of xxx found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Source: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0821638/reviews
0 Response to "Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee Reviews by Natives"
Postar um comentário